From my Forbes.com blog The New Persuaders:
To hear Silicon Valley and nouveau ad-tech types tell it, traditional advertising sucks. The best way to attract people’s attention and engage them more fully is to create ad formats that more closely resemble the activities people are already doing on a site–in other words, to make ads look less like ads.
That’s the idea behind so-called “native” ads such as Facebook’s Sponsored Stories and Twitter’s Promoted Tweets. Although various studies seem to indicate these ads are indeed more effective than standard banner ads–a low bar, it must be said–a new survey released today indicates that a lot of consumers don’t trust native ads. According to the survey by app advertising firm MediaBrix and Harris Interactive:
* 45% found Twitter promoted tweets misleading.
* 57% found Facebook sponsored stories misleading.
* 86% found sponsored video ads that appear to be content misleading.
The survey also found that a large majority of people who have seen Twitter Promoted Tweets in the past 12 months said they hurt or had no impact on their perception of the brand advertised. Some 72% said the same thing about Facebook’s Sponsored Stories. And 85% found sponsored video ads didn’t leave them with warm feelings. “While anyone pushing the native ad agenda or otherwise would agree that we need to provide user experiences that are not jarring or disruptive, we also need to ensure that we are direct and honest with our consumers about when they are being marketed to,” MediaBrix CEO Ari Brandt said. “Some formats achieve this better than others.”
Mind some caveats about this research. For one, it doesn’t compare native ads to banner ads, so there’s no telling whether trust in banner ads is any better than these native ads. Also, what people say they feel about ads and brands may have little to do with the ads’ effectiveness. And MediaBrix has a dog in this hunt, since it offers its own kinds of ad formats for social and mobile apps.
Still, it’s a splash of cold water on a trend that some very high-profile companies are counting on to become the next Google. And it’s a lesson that marketers apparently constantly need to be reminded about: Don’t try to fool your customers, because it can destroy trust in your brand.